I'm willing to give LGBT books the benefit of the doubt. I have slightly lower standards because I'm just so excited to see my community represented. I'll overlook the big, gaping plot holes you could drive a bus through, poorly imagined worlds, bad characterization, and horrific prose just to get my fix. (I do try to be rational while reviewing, though)
Therefore, in my head, as I read, I always keep in mind my mom, who is also an avid reader of fiction of the lighthearted, not-too-serious variety. However, unlike me, she doesn't read queer fiction solely for the presence of queerness. She has nothing against queer fiction, and has read many an m/m or f/f book with delight, but it has to pass the test of being a good, solid story. Understand, it's not that she "overlooks" the queerness. She doesn't care one way or the other. She just wants a good read. So as I read, I think of my mom. "Will this book pass the Mom Test?"
What follows are two lists of books. The first are books that have officially passed the Mom Test. She read them, and then she excitedly talked with me about them for over an hour on the phone (wow, that was a lot of prepositions). The second list includes books that I haven't gotten around to recommending to her or she hasn't gotten around to reading, but I
think will pass the Mom Test.
( The Mom Index )This entry was originally posted at
http://fire-juggler.dreamwidth.org/7825.html.